My normal mince pie recipe is more or less Nigella's frangipane one from
How to be a Domestic Goddess (but with plain shortcrust pastry instead of the almondy one she uses). It's the mince pie recipe which converts everyone who eats one, however much they thought they didn't like mince pies to begin with. I think often the reason people don't like them is that they've only eaten shop-bought ones, which consist of an enormous wodge of tasteless, textureless pastry filled with an even more enormous amount of mincmeat (something people tend to be a bit wary of anyway), and the end result is pretty horrible. The frangipane pies, on the other hand, contain just enough mincemeat to give them flavour, but not so much as to be hard work; and the almondy topping makes a change from pastry.
This year, though, I had one of my 'what if' moments. I wondered whether the same arrangement would work with breadcrumbs in place of the ground almonds. And then I was
reading that frangipane "is derived from
frangere il pane (Italian for 'break the bread')" which seemed like permission to try it out, if permission were needed. And so began an experiment in
terror pies...
The pastry
I don't get why people worry about making pastry. It's basically just taking a few ingredients and smooshing them together into a paste...
You want twice as much flour as fat - so, I've got 100g plain flour and 50g butter, cut into small cubes. Chuck in a pinch of salt as well. Rub the lumps of butter into the flour with your fingertips until they look like fattish, clumpy breadcrumbs.
Then stir in some liquid (I had a whole plan to use orange juice, and put the orange zest in the pie topping, but I forgot all about it until I found the orange after I'd finished making the pies, so I actually just used water) to bind it together - go very slowly, a spoonful at a time, and stop as soon as you can stick the mixture together to make a dough.
Wrap the dough in clingfilm and stick it in the fridge for twenty minutes or so.
The mincemeat
I generally make my own mincemeat - I used a jar of something cherry-ish which was lurking at the back of my baking cupboard for this - but bought is fine. I used about two thirds of the jar (no idea how much that weighs because I didn't check) and mixed a grated apple into it. (If it was bought mincemeat, I'd probably have added some lemon juice, too.)
Pie assembly part one
Roll out the pastry (make sure to flour the worksurface so it doesn't stick) and cut circles with a cutter or a glass - you need them slightly larger than the dents in your bun tray. The quantities here should be enough for about two dozen mince pies, but you can always do two lots of twelve if you only have one tray.
Sit the pastry circles in the (buttered) tray.
Put a teaspoonful of mincemeat into each pastry hollow. You don't want to fill them up to the top - don't worry if it looks a bit parsimonious; it'll turn out just right.
The topping
You need 90g breadcrumbs - I used the remains of a cranberry baguette (which sounded like a good idea when I bought it, and explains why the breadcrumbs look a bit pink) but pretty much anything plain or sweet would work.
(Incidentally, the cunning measuring device in the picture is a
Cook's Dry Measure. They're properly brilliant. If you don't have one, you want one for Christmas. It includes measurements for all kinds of dry ingredients, and although technically you aren't supposed to use it for liquids I do, all the time, and have yet to bring about the end of the universe.)
I was a bit wary about whether the breadcrumb topping would just turn to mush, so I decided to toast the breadcrumbs - I just spread them out on a tray and sprinkled on a bit of sugar, shoved the whole thing under the grill, watched it
very carefully and did lots of stirring to stop it from burning.
To make the topping, beat together 2 eggs and 90g sugar, and stir in 90g melted butter. Then mix in the breadcrumbs.
Pie assembly part two
Add a spoonful of the topping to each pie - not too much, as it'll puff up a bit and if you go mad with it at this point it'll just end up flowing across the bun tray like lava once it goes in the oven.
Put them in the oven at 200C for 15 minutes or so, until the top is puffed up and golden and the pastry is cooked.
My experience is that you need to get these out of the trays while they're still hot - especially any that have erupted - or the sugar in the topping will more or less weld them in place as it cools. If any of the pies turn out to be not quite cooked underneath, stick them back in the oven upside down for another minute or two.
The verdict
I am
so pleased with these. They work! Not just in a 'not awful' way; I actually like them more than the almond version. These are simultaneously chewier and more brittle, and the topping just is - I don't suppose anyone would know it was made of breadcrumbs if you didn't tell them. I may test it out tomorrow. Assuming they last that long...